andygates: (Default)
andygates ([personal profile] andygates) wrote2009-12-02 09:44 pm
Entry tags:

First Look: Cool-er Ebook Reader

I've been looking at readers for a few weeks, and today had a play in The Shoppe and succumbed to the Cool-er. Mostly because I think a reader should be fairly invisible, a portal not a gadget, and the competition (the Sony PRS-300 Pocket Reader) was much too cluttered with buttons around the page. I got both devices in my hand and it was a no-brainer.

The Cool-er fits my "magic size and shape" - a DVD case. It's a little narrower and slimmer, and weighs exactly the same as a DVD in its box - ie, bugger-all. The Sony was much more of a Quality Gadget - Sony don't make anything else - but it was heavier and thicker and just more gadgety. It's a thing of beauty and Sony fans will be righteous in their love, but I don't even want to see the reader, let alone squee over it.

The Cool-er also does HTML which the Sony doesn't, and quiet a bit of my stuff is HTML.

There's no software with it: you manage it all with file folders or you get Adobe Digital Editions for the DRM stuff (yeah, riiiight). That suits me just fine. Charging is handled through the USB cable, so it should charge fine from ad-hoc USB chargers like the FreeLoader if you need to.

It takes SD cards up to 4Gb, which is total overkill for books but not for PDFs which get hefty - if you're a PDF slut like me, this is ace. The crazy-toothed survivalist library can easily tuck in one corner of a big SD card without getting in the way, waiting the zombie apocalypse.

Graphics are okay - 8 greys, very rich PDFs look a bit arse (zines no, papers with graphs yes). Page turns are fast for its class.

[identity profile] andygates.livejournal.com 2009-12-02 10:38 pm (UTC)(link)
The DRM is with Adobe Digital Editions. You get a book on one computer and registered devices, and there's some loan and re-download support. They can't suck books from the device the way Amazon did, as far as I can see. I haven't looked into it much deeper but take a look at coolerbooks.com - the sales end is not as fresh as the Amazon or B&N stores at first glance.

When I go shopping, I'll report back on the experience; for now I'm gorging on the glut of stuff I already have.

There are some UI annoyances. The status bar setting is forgotten on reboot (you should never need to, but apparently corrupted PDFs bounce it); the folder navigation is a little wonky compared to how I'd intuit it, but nothing insane. I like the fairly stiff, clicky buttons - that's another design decision I agree with that some reviewers hate.
calum: (Default)

[personal profile] calum 2009-12-03 12:17 am (UTC)(link)
Does it cope with large PDF files?

E.g. if sad geek me wanted to put a 500 page RPG rulebook on there, would it work?

Can it follow PDF bookmarks?
Edited 2009-12-03 00:17 (UTC)

[identity profile] andygates.livejournal.com 2009-12-03 07:04 am (UTC)(link)
The screen's not big enough for RPG rulebooks, really. You can make and use bookmarks; I'm not sure if it picks up on bookmarks set up within the PDF (I'm not a great PF boi; I'll check with some technical manuals at work later).

[identity profile] thudthwacker.livejournal.com 2009-12-03 02:23 pm (UTC)(link)
The DRM is with Adobe Digital Editions. You get a book on one computer and registered devices, and there's some loan and re-download support.

Meh. I'm kinda hoping that the whole DRM stupidity in ebooks eventually gets tossed down the chute, to reside in the Bad Idea Dumpster next to DRM in music.

[identity profile] andygates.livejournal.com 2009-12-03 02:46 pm (UTC)(link)
Likewise. I have no love nor regard for it.