andygates: (Default)
2009-03-05 02:58 pm
Entry tags:

Wiki Theory

Is there a formula to describe the function of a wiki?  I've seen lots of wikis work, and lots fail, and there's always some critical mass at which point the thing becomes self-sustaining (analogous to the number of neurons or flops needed for consciousness?).  Wikipedia owns the world.  The department knowledgebase died three times, so it's not having a number of wiki zealots or super-contributors.

I have a hunch that there's some very nebuolous critical factor.  That might go some way to explaining the reactions of wiki-zealots and wiki-decriers, both of whom see wiki projects in pretty concrete ways.  It feels like the argument for abiogenesis: one group see the huge physical and time scales and their gut says, "P tends toward 1"; another group say "P tends toward 0 for that unlikely reaction" and need to invoke an outside agency (mmm, tastes like God). 
andygates: (Default)
2008-12-30 12:44 pm
Entry tags:

Wiki world: OpenStreetMap

My fad of the moment, this: OpenStreetMap is a wiki world map.  Why?  Well, the regular world maps are fine but they're copyright material, so there are limits and costs on what you can do with 'em, and they update once a yawnellium.  OSM lets you edit it yourself and do whatever you like with the data.  The online editor is too simple to be fun but the downloadable 'JOSM' editor's a breeze.  You upload GPS traces then draw over them and add POI and metadata as you go.  The editable map is re-rendered midweek so those weekend geo-nerding trips' results are all live by next weekend.

The main online map is kinda dull, but the possibilities are much more entertaining.  Because there are cycle route categories, for example, someone's written a render that highlights cycle routes and minor roads, dims trunk roads, and has bike parking, bike shops and bike hire POI - and made it a Garmin file.  Another chap has piped it as a layer over Blue Marble. 

Of course there arise the usual wiki questions of reliability, completeness and partisan editing.  What if someone goofed?  What if your town isn't there (Crediton mostly isn't, though someone is filling it in now - must have got a GPS for Christmas)?  And what if you've got Aaron123 and Ahmed2009 both editing the hell out of Gaza?  Well, those are all valid questions, but the stunning success of good wiki projects suggests that they're all soluble without too much sweat: correct errors you see; find local rambler zealots and feed them gap lists; apply the mod-stick and lock certain areas.  Right now, it's about where Wikipedia was in 2002, back when you could easily add whole sections, but even so the general coverage is very good. 

It'd make a great class project: draw the local area map as part of a whole local-geography, history-of-maps thing.
andygates: (Default)
2008-03-19 09:31 am

Wikihistory

This short-short is shamelessly lifted from BoingBoing but I'm just in love with the idea: With easy time travel, history becomes an edit war.  And in any edit war, most of the time is spent slapping down the noobs.

At 14:52:28, FreedomFighter69 wrote:
Reporting my first temporal excursion since joining IATT: have just returned from 1936 Berlin, having taken the place of one of Leni Riefenstahl's cameramen and assassinated Adolf Hitler during the opening of the Olympic Games. Let a free world rejoice!

At 14:57:44, SilverFox316 wrote:
Back from 1936 Berlin; incapacitated FreedomFighter69 before he could pull his little stunt. Freedomfighter69, as you are a new member, please read IATT Bulletin 1147 regarding the killing of Hitler before your next excursion. Failure to do so may result in your expulsion per Bylaw 223.

At 18:06:59, BigChill wrote:
Take it easy on the kid, SilverFox316; everybody kills Hitler on their first trip. I did. It always gets fixed within a few minutes, what's the harm?

andygates: (Default)
2007-08-17 01:34 pm
Entry tags:

Standlone wiki on a USB key?

My ISP is down.  There is vexation among the masses, particularly as I need one set of contact details soon or a real-world transaction will bork.  C'est la risk of putting a bunch of stuff on a wiki online; it's available everywhere, but it's very unavailable if the ISP does the dying fly.  So I'm sat here like a lemon, fighting the urge to go to treeware despite its many and obvious suckings.

"Munky!  We need more technodgeoly"